Why Expected Credit Loss Makes Commercial Sense
Expected credit loss connects receivable balances to the evidence about collection. Used during the year, that discipline can improve credit terms, collections and discussions with lenders and owners.

Xian Hui
6 November 2026 · 7 min read

In brief
Why does expected credit loss make commercial sense?
Expected credit loss asks a business to assess what it expects to collect using customer evidence, past experience and reasonable forecasts. Those are also the inputs to sound credit management. Used during the year, the assessment can inform credit terms, pricing, collection priorities and discussions with lenders and owners. Its value depends on connecting the estimate to decisions and updating it as evidence changes.
What you'll learn
- Connect ECL estimates with customer knowledge and credit decisions
- Recognise deterioration using collection evidence and forward-looking information
- Use credit loss information when reviewing pricing, payment terms and collections
- Explain allowance movements to lenders and owners
Why Expected Credit Loss Makes Commercial Sense
A business can report a sale, pay its staff and suppliers, and still wait for the customer to pay. Granting credit commits the business's own cash. Understanding the prospect of collection belongs in the decision to make that commitment.
Our view is that accounting standards make commercial sense when applied properly. Expected credit loss (ECL) illustrates the point: it asks management to connect the amount owed with evidence about what the business expects to receive.
IFRS 9 Financial Instruments (equivalent to SFRS(I) 9 and SFRS 109) requires an unbiased estimate reflecting possible outcomes, the time value of money and reasonable, supportable information [IFRS 9.5.5.17]. These requirements give credit management a useful discipline.
Why did IFRS 9 introduce expected credit losses?
IAS 39 used an incurred loss model, which recognised credit losses only once a loss event had happened. The global financial crisis that started in 2007 exposed weaknesses: credit losses on loans were recognised too late, and multiple impairment approaches made the requirements complex. The G20 and others raised concerns about the delayed recognition of credit losses [IFRS 9 Basis for Conclusions].
In October 2008, the IASB and FASB set up the Financial Crisis Advisory Group. Its July 2009 report recommended exploring alternatives to the incurred loss model that used more forward-looking information [IFRS 9 Basis for Conclusions].
The IASB issued the completed IFRS 9 in July 2014, replacing IAS 39's incurred loss model with an expected credit loss model, effective for annual periods beginning on or after 1 January 2018 [IFRS 9.7.1.1]. The commercial point is that the model was designed to show deterioration earlier.
How are ECL allowances measured?
An allowance begins with a reliable understanding of the receivables. Finance needs to know the debtor, the amount owed, the agreed terms and the collection history. At a macro level, the team needs to understand the economic context, business environment and regulatory framework in which the debtor operates.
The same applies to loans and cash deposits outside the sales ledger. Their recoverability depends on the counterparty and the agreement. Our explanation of 12-month and lifetime ECL covers the different measurement approaches. The commercial starting point is knowing the exposure.
Why should finance and sales work together on credit?
To gather this information, the finance team often needs to work very closely with sales and management. The first business benefit is that two teams that often work in silos now need to talk to each other.
Through these conversations, accountants understand customers better and the sales team understands the risks better. This helps the business detect risks earlier and take better recovery action.
If a customer's apparent growth comes with repeated requests for longer terms, the business needs to assess the extra credit exposure it is accepting. Whoever owns the customer relationship should also take responsibility for supplying relevant payment information.
Why should management look for deterioration before payments fail?
By the time an invoice is seriously overdue, the opportunity to change the next sale may have passed. Warning signs can emerge earlier through requests for concessions, weakening trading conditions or repeated difficulty meeting commitments. A conversation can reveal something an ageing report cannot.
Under the general approach, default risk is compared with the risk at initial recognition [IFRS 9.5.5.9]. Reasonable forward-looking information is required when available without undue cost or effort [IFRS 9.5.5.11]. This encourages attention to changing circumstances while decisions can still respond.
For trade receivables using lifetime ECL from the outset, monitoring remains necessary. The loss horizon stays the same, but the expected loss can change. Management should ask whether a customer's circumstances have weakened even when the invoice has not yet fallen due.
Why should sales targets reflect credit risk?
Sales growth is welcome, but failed collections can reduce the profit those sales appear to generate. Reflecting expected credit losses in profit or loss helps management see the effect of credit risk on performance [IFRS 9.5.5.8]. When reviewing sales targets and performance, management can consider the profit expected after credit losses as well as the sales booked. This can encourage sales and management to consider credit risk from the outset, when deciding which sales to pursue.
For example, a customer may operate in a jurisdiction facing conflict or sanctions. If historical experience, current conditions and reasonable forecasts support a higher risk of default for that customer's credit profile, that evidence should inform the ECL assessment. Management can then consider whether the margin on the proposed deal is sufficient to compensate for the expected credit loss.
How can ECL inform pricing and credit terms?
When reviewing terms for future orders, management should consider expected losses alongside funding costs, customer strategy and the strength of the relationship.
Possible responses include asking for a deposit, reducing a credit limit or agreeing shorter payment terms. A different price may be appropriate for future business. ECL does not prescribe any of these decisions. It supplies information management can use to assess them.
The estimate must still reflect the evidence fairly. A commercial desire to retain a customer cannot justify suppressing the allowance, just as concern about the next year's results cannot justify overstating it. The unbiased measurement requirement supports a more honest assessment of the relationship [IFRS 9.5.5.17].
What should collections conversations contribute to the estimate?
Collections teams hear explanations that accounting records may capture late. A broken payment commitment, a request for restructuring or evidence of improved trading can change the assessment of recovery. Finance needs a way to record that information and judge its relevance.
Establish what the customer owes and why payment is delayed. A genuine disagreement about the invoice may require resolving the underlying sale. Financial difficulty raises a different collection question. Clear records help management choose the appropriate response.
Evidence of recovery deserves the same care as evidence of deterioration. Modifying terms without derecognising the asset does not automatically reduce credit risk [IFRS 9.B5.5.27]. A new promise should be assessed alongside payment performance and the reasons the customer needed the concession.
Why should management challenge last year's provision rates?
A provision matrix can organise the estimate, but its rates need to remain relevant to the customers and conditions being assessed. Historical experience must reflect present conditions and forecasts, and methods and assumptions need regular review [IFRS 9.B5.5.52].
Management can ask whether customer groups still share similar risks, whether recent recoveries support the assumptions and whether economic changes affect particular customers. Documenting the evidence makes judgement easier to challenge. Extra calculation detail adds little if nobody can explain why the rates remain suitable.
How does the allowance improve conversations with lenders and owners?
An allowance movement can prompt useful questions about the business. Did receivables grow, did customer quality weaken, or did new evidence change the estimate? A lower allowance could reflect improved collection, but it could also follow writing off balances that are no longer recoverable.
A write-off is required when there is no reasonable expectation of recovering all or part of the asset [IFRS 9.5.4.4]. The required allowance adjustment goes through profit or loss [IFRS 9.5.5.8]. Explaining both helps an owner or lender understand why the closing allowance alone cannot describe performance.
The discussion should connect management accounts and financial statements to the same underlying collection evidence. Owners can then question the return from extending credit, while lenders can assess the quality of receivables supporting the business's funding needs.
Why does a provision booked once a year miss the point?
The accounting requirements apply at each reporting date. Commercially, management gains more by reviewing credit evidence as business develops. That can mean bringing sales, finance and collections together to review changed circumstances and decisions about further exposure.
The standard does not prescribe that meeting or its frequency. The useful habit is to record what changed, decide what action follows and carry the evidence into the next assessment. It also makes the eventual reporting exercise easier to explain.
As with our discussion of how presentation requirements support commercial judgement, the information earns its value through use. ECL makes commercial sense when the estimate informs decisions about the money the business expects to collect.
Frequently asked questions
This information has been prepared for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be relied upon as accounting, tax, or other professional advice.


